Defense MAY be overtuned
Traded for a decent pitcher from the Royals, thinking he'd be a good #3 - and he turned into a Cy Young candidate. Either I've assembled a god tier defensive squad or KC tried trotting out 9 first basemen.
| 20-80 Scale | NYY | KC |
|---|---|---|
| C - Block/Frame/Arm | 70/65/55 | 65/60/70 |
| 1B - Height/Range/Error/Arm/DP | 6'6"/50/45/40/50 | 6'2"/40/35/35/35 |
| 2B - Range/Error/Arm/DP | 65/60/50/50 | 65/55/60/60 |
| 3B - Range/Error/Arm/DP | 50/50/60/35 | 55/50/65/60 |
| SS - Range/Error/Arm/DP | 70/60/60/70 | 50/55/40/65 |
| LF - Range/Error/Arm | 65/55/50 | 65/60/45 |
| CF - Range/Error/Arm | 75/55/50 | 60/55/60 |
| RF - Range/Error/Arm | 60/65/55 | 65/60/65 |
No idea why KC doesn't flip their SS & 2B, but that can't make THAT much of a difference, can it?
14 comments · 61% upvoted · other discussions
regression incoming
thisusedyet [OP] 1 points · Sep 2026
You were right, had a bad June and August, that cost him
Still had an insane run in the Cy Young voting - Hermenegildo is my closer, so I had my #3 win the Cy, my #2 came in 2nd, my #4 that went on a run came 4th, my (injured) ace came 5th, and my closer came in 8th with a pity vote from somebody
https://preview.redd.it/06gjd6apaeph1.png?width=1987&format=png&auto=webp&s=2d7cec0ea22dd95dfeed9adc379a04a107686213