Should I stain this - or leave as-is?

1 points · submitted Dec 2025 by u/berry120 · Question

I'm building a flowerpot rail as a gift. The dowel is pretty cheap - just 20mm pine. I can't work out if a darker stain would make it look a bit nicer - or I should just leave as is (looking around I see a bunch of mixed comments on whether staining pine is worthwhile or not.)

Complete novice and don't have a particularly great eye for these things - so happy to take any suggestions!

6 comments · 67% upvoted · source · other discussions

comments

[deleted] 3 points · Dec 2025

Finish it in oil based poly. It’ll look great. I like total boat spar finish for this stuff because you can apply all the coats in a day and can confirm it holds up very well. I’d attach a picture of my coffee table but I can’t.

permalink

berry120 [OP] 1 points · Dec 2025

Thank you!

permalink

[deleted] 1 points · Dec 2025

Of course, if you were local I’d let you use my tent but brush it on and you’ll be good

permalink

RunningWarrior 3 points · Dec 2025

Maybe it’s just me, but if I ever have to ask myself this question, the answer is always boiled linseed oil. Danish oil if I’m feeling fancy.

permalink

RoleUnusual220 1 points · Dec 2025

As another absolute novice, I second the linseed oil advice. Just made my first worktable out of pine and listened to these guys about using BLO; brought out a beautiful honey color i was very satisfied with!

permalink

TheArtistOnceKnown 1 points · Dec 2025

A birch dowel wil cost you only a couple of bucks more, and it would look beautiful natural

permalink