The race to extract an Indigenous language from its last lucid speaker
7 comments · 100% upvoted · source · other discussions
7 comments · 100% upvoted · source · other discussions
Oof 😬 That's an ethical nightmare of a headline. In social science research, consultants above data, people. The ones using languages are living humans, not fossils buried in the ground.
Pretty horrifying way to word that headline. Extract?
paigem212 5 points · Dec 2024
I mean, with any culture, an academic coming to collect information that is not also participating in the culture/instantly making said information digestible and available to that culture is inherently extractive. Even then, sometimes it’s still extractive because it’s being utilized in an institution that is actively trying to make sure marginalized communities are unable to succeed. Academia can be horrifying and complex even when it’s attempting to do good. It’s worthy recognizing something is extractive to make sure we’re always trying to do better for Indigenous communities.
ColdDistribution2848 9 points · Dec 2024
Having been the subject of coercive, exploitative and extractive academic research, I'm unfortunately already aware, it's just that seeing it phrased that way in the headline hit me for some reason
paigem212 3 points · Dec 2024
Completely understandable
Freshiiiiii 4 points · Dec 2024
‘elicit’ would definitely have been the better word.