u/baru_monkey
baru_monkey
baru_monkey
"I've heard that the minions in this game are a Cere and Scarlet Woman"
I would still flag that as a madness break, as they couldn't actually know that
baru_monkey
meetup.com
baru_monkey
That's also the only one I placed before getting stuck! I'm moving on to using hints.
baru_monkey
Yes, but don't.
baru_monkey
Duplicate cere madness confirms the narcissist
Duplicate washerwoman pings confirms the narcissist
Confirmation is OP for the good team
baru_monkey
but they don't care that it's risky; it's for the lols
baru_monkey
work itself out as this will often result in them losing
but they don't care about losing
baru_monkey
Good can't win if you both live.
baru_monkey
I don't think they are. Don't assume intent.
baru_monkey
applause
baru_monkey
That just means Evil wins TB 47-50% of the time, which sounds fully accurate to me.
baru_monkey
And this "confirmed Spy" makes it an excellent starpass target!
baru_monkey
No, I don't think it would be interesting anywhere. Just a funny concept.
baru_monkey
Is this surprising in any way?
baru_monkey
It's literally been about 11 years.
baru_monkey
nope
baru_monkey
I, for one, appreciate the shorter format!
baru_monkey
The Slayer uses up their once per game ability whoever they use it on. But if the target happens to be a Recluse, and they die, then that special case confirms the Slayer (who otherwise would not be confirmed).
baru_monkey
True, fair point. Similar to a Virgin only mostly-confirming the person they kill.
It still treats an Outsider like a Townsfolk for confirmation-power reasons, so it is still a YBD.
baru_monkey
register as the demon if they get slayer shot. Although that's not really a yes but don't 😅
Yes, it is a yes but don't -- it hard-confirms two good players
...
...
The debate is on the expectation of execution.