u/grapp

253.6k post karma · 20.6k comment karma · joined Oct 2012 · moderator

  1. 54points

    From the way Robert described it I worry people might get the impression Britain didn’t experience the post war economic boom at all, and that isn’t accurate. (self.behindthebastards) [General discussion ]

    55 comments

  2. 74points

    you know what just happened in Brazil, do you think either Trump's victories would been prevented if US elections had second rounds? (self.behindthebastards) [Politics]

    31 comments

  3. 61points

    a subtle bit of world building in Against a Dark Background that I like; various kind of advanced off road vehicles are common on Golter because all their roads are privately owned and have a shit ton of tolls (self.TheCulture) [Tangential to the Culture]

    9 comments

  4. 2points

    [Dies the Fire/Emberverse]we’re told the armour worn by British military officers is modelled on the 15th century plate armour but modified to be ergonomic enough that you can take it off and on without help. What would that mean in practice? (self.AskScienceFiction)

    4 comments

  5. 45points

    Something I often wonder about the Culture; To what extent is its desire not to be seen as overtly imperialist just because it’d pissing off the other Involved species if they were, rather than because it’s what the Minds actually want do? (self.TheCulture) [General Discussion]

    54 comments

  6. 19points

    you know what was something I always wanted to see that non of the shows ever thought to do? A full scale FTL ship but shaped like an old school submarine so it can go through regular stargates (self.Stargate) [Discussion]

    49 comments

  7. 0points

    Do you think it’s possible to separate being anti-AI from being anti-computer technology advancing in general? And if “yes” is that something people on the left need to rhetorically do? (self.behindthebastards) [General discussion ]

    41 comments

  8. 611points

    The Jimmy Savile Episodes talked a lot about how Jimmy used being perceived as "eccentric" to get people to disregard all the obvious red flags he displayed. Do you think Russell Brand did/does the same kind of thing? (self.behindthebastards) [Look at this bastard]

    152 comments

  9. 178points

    Jason seems to think Trump actually winning in 2016 disproved his theory that he was originally running as a publicity stunt, but I don’t think it does at all disprove that. (self.behindthebastards) [General discussion ]

    46 comments

  10. 47points

    If someone consistently uses streaming to broadcast themselves committing crimes, particularly harassing people, should it be a crime for sites to knowingly give them a platform? (self.behindthebastards) [Discussion]

    20 comments

  11. 102points

    you know what'd be a good spiritual sequel to the John Landis episodes? the story of how director Victor Salva was convicted of child molestation in 1988 and still had a Hollywood career for decades after that because Francis Ford Coppola liked him (self.behindthebastards) [Look at this bastard]

    19 comments

  12. 4points

    [Pantheon]they sent Caspian to real school with other kids, how do they know he wouldn’t experience something there that’d totally change his personality? (self.AskScienceFiction) [spoiler]

    3 comments

grapp

large numbers of council homes being sold off actually started in the 70s under Edward Heath.

people like to imagine Neolibralism came in all in one go with Thatcher and Reagan, but in both the US and UK there were elements of it in preceding governments

grapp

I'd have rather lived in the US only if I could be white.

grapp

I didn't say you did, I just think people might get that impression from what you did say.

grapp

there's a lot of authors who're good at world building but not actually telling compelling stories set within them.

Banks could do both

grapp

You knew a lot of people who’d read the books?

grapp

In theory anyone who knows about the Culture can travel and live there. They just don’t actively take measures to make that easier.

Doing that would probably do more harm than good in the long run because the Culture would have to take military action against authoritarian societies that don’t want to let their people leave. Even if the Culture could theoretically just overwhelm a society like the Azadians in a situation like that, seeing the Culture act like that would probably piss off other involved species the Culture is on a more equal footing on with.

grapp

you could turn the gate on its back then have the ship fly in through the shaft they use to get the gate from the surface

grapp

yes

grapp

Minds, culture citizens in general but Minds especially, are encouraged to have a sense of honour because it’s a way of promoting ethical behaviour in the absence of punishment.

Like culture Minds can effectively do whatever they want but a sense they will have shamed themselves if they act in an unethical way is what keeps the vast majority of them on the straight and narrow.

grapp

“And zero plan for what to do if they did” which is why his first term ended up being much more like a normal republican presidency than his second. The first time they didn’t have a plan to properly capitalize on the fascist momentum they’d built up

grapp

I mean the thing you'd probably do is just fine them enough so they can't profit from it

grapp

I feel like what makes Victor Salva unusually egregious is the fact that since he was actually convicted his past was entirely known to everyone and he got work in spite of that. Like no one who’s hired him or worked with him in the last 38 years has plausible deniability about knowing he’s a pedophile

grapp

....God can't have hated him that much if he's a free man