u/shgrdrbr
shgrdrbr
shgrdrbr
because genitals don't determine whether you are a woman or not. trans women know they are women. transness predates bottom surgery. the idea that you are not a woman until a procedure is done to you supposes you gender is something externally given to you by someone else but the entire concept of gender identity exists because of the conflict that arises when someone calls you by the markers of a gender you know you aren't.
so-called "biological sex" is not even as clear-cut as the received narrative would have you believe. sex is allegedly down to chromosomes, xx/xy, but also down to genitals, but also down to secondary sex characteristics, and also down to hormones... so what if you are born with vagina, xx chromosomes, but high testosterone that causes thick body and facial hair? what if you're born with a penis but xx chromosomes and high levels of oestrogen? what if you're born with indeterminate genitals at birth and your parents decide it's neater if your maybe-penis were a big clit and have it surgically corrected at birth and raise you as a girl but then you can't fight how wrong it feels as you grow up? etc. trans people get surgery to be read as the correct gender but this is a social thing; how viscerally their own self-concept relies on a particular genital/how present dysphoria is based on it will generally have to do with how essential that is to an individuals' visceral understanding of gender itself. the notion that girls can't have dicks is a constraint imposed by a scientific orthodoxy that developed out of convenience and with deference to power structures, not actual biology nor social "truth".
it makes immediate sense to me that to buy into the notion that you must undergo surgery to be "really" trans you are undermining the truth of queerness in order to submit it to a transphobic compulsorily heterosexual standard for acceptance. it is for some reasonably experienced as a form of violent self-denial (i.e. that this body is not a woman's body even though it is the body a woman possesses). and socially passing as a woman is down to visible stuff like boobs, face, hair, voice; between-me-down-there isn't what people see immediately and only a select few may get access so it's not gonna impede social functioning it's just for you. ive heard genitals can feel pretty pleasurable, if you don't feel a deep shame and wrongness and incompatibility with ur genitals then keep em as feels good!
shgrdrbr
ohhhh god protect these children
eta jesus downvoting an expression of hope that children are ok is actually insane. this sub is so weird. i'm not a bible thumper but you guys need to refocus your anger
shgrdrbr
my brother who isnt really religious at all met his wife (bit more religious but not loadsss) on Minder. could be a shout!
shgrdrbr
he, then 23, proposed to you, 14!?????? this guy was a creep and paedophile. you need to be much more careful about making 'friendships' with older strangers. he was not your friend, he was a paedophile who was interested in exploiting you.
shgrdrbr
no seriously joel is extra hot nowwwww
shgrdrbr
haleys parents were CRAZY for that literally like well kid you're married now so no-one's left in the nest, at 16 we will leave you to fend for yourself with only your troubled boyfriend who is also in high school and emancipated from his abusive parents who hate you. good luck! say bye forever to your childhood bedroom and parental support! no more safe place to land for you!!
shgrdrbr
what else was it going to be? this was always the conclusion. you are a walking advert, your life is an advert, your body your clothes your face = advert
shgrdrbr
ugly evil twit
shgrdrbr
sorry but piss off. if the government coerces you to wear hijab on pain of physical brutalisation it's obviously not a choice. exactly the same if the government coerces you to strip off on pain of physical brutalisation. that doesn't mean any time you choose to take your clothes off it's not a choice just the same as voluntarily choosing to dress modestly isn't suddenly impossible. you are indoctrinated if you can't see that.
shgrdrbr
NAH but i understand if she feels embarrassed and that's valid, it's fair if she prefer you don't go into her work and would be nice if you compromised but also i am a lil worried both of you were so chill about her doing unpaid overtime! she should be taught and made aware it's not in her interest to donate her time freely to a company that is inherently already exploiting her. obviously that doesn't mean go be a karen making demands but just in a general way this sentiment of "she doesn't have to clock out" if she isn't getting paid for the work she's doing past time, i'd counter with, she does have to clock out, and learn that her time is valuable and not to be given to corporate overlords.
shgrdrbr
it's obnoxious cliches delivered as if theyre some rousing hilarity. her talent show song was about THE WEATHER!!!! it irritated me so much that it won tbh literally all the other songs were funny despite their cringe, like alik's natalie cassidyyyyy was funnier than any line in her song. she hasn't been funny ONCE. the only time she was close to funny was when she set paris baby up with the overweight line but literally only bc i THOUGHT she was gen setting her up with that convoluted-ass luggage sentence
shgrdrbr
spooky scary! somethin kinda HOT
shgrdrbr
OP sounds like a psycho and they are TA: "I have no problem with her reading or writing or doing stuff on her own. I just don't get why she can't include me, too. Like, if she's reading sommething, why doesn't she tell me what she's reading and talk to me about it? Or, since she likes fiction, why doesn't she try to tell me about it?"
shgrdrbr
why are they so stupid i want to bang my head against the wall
shgrdrbr
im with this!
shgrdrbr
in fact ukraine is much more complicated. the ukrainian state is stealing poor kids to send to the front to be blown up, many ukrainians are nazis
shgrdrbr
oh i see i skimmed that part thank you. tbh i liveeee for leftovers so while i understand the frustration for sure id also be a little bit like YES to get to eat more of the high effort delicious meal than expected
shgrdrbr
what happens to his leftovers, they just get thrown out?
shgrdrbr
it's exhausting that now internet kids self-righteously will determine "ahh, mental illness doesn;'t have anything to do with someone acting in a way i dont like" because only anxiety and depression are real or something? lol
shgrdrbr
exactly. like even the most popular comments in this discussion pertain to kanye and excusing kanye bc he's mentally ill while calling azealia 'evil for no reason'...like she's also incredibly fucking unwell and has had SO much less support both public and private, socially emotionally reputationally financially. like back in the day when people were obsessed with slating her for homophobia when her music is explicitly undeniably queer and she started from a place of reading culture vulture white gays who thought they had the audacity to qualify her or not. she's faced so much disrespect and lived lives most of us cant even imagine, met untold harms, had v little safety net. i cant actively support her since she became a z10nist shill bc it's beyond the pale of harm but i hate the way people draw a line around her generally regardless of that and say "dont feel bad for her bc she's bigoted" like YOU'RE freaking bigoted for saying this about an obviously severely mentally damaged queer Black woman who has seen into the darkest parts of the industry (and life before too)
shgrdrbr
i think a lot of americans see buzzwords and immediately revert to hallmark tropes and assume they have to play out an intervention? i too was surprised
shgrdrbr
the comprehension here is so depressing i am really shocked the way people are reading this because of tropes they're used to.
shgrdrbr
and definitely don't date Actually Abusive
shgrdrbr
this getting reflexively downvoted is so depressing. people are so keen to celebrate no animal testing for the aesthetic and get irritated by the reminder that the skin of palestinians is seemingly valued less
lol absolutely commensurate response~!