Turkish Astra Green?

I got these from Amazon a while back and read a thread about fake astra greens last night and decided to look at these.

Hopefully you can see the text if you zoom in, I tried to take closer pictures but my phone couldn’t take them any closer with it getting very blurry.

When reading about these blades online I have only heard of them coming from Russia and more recently India.

These seem to be made in Istanbul?

I left out a picture of one of the long sides of the box since it was completely blank.

There is apparently no date where there usually is and instead there seems to be some sort of manufacturer code.

If I try to shave a third time with these blades they are awful. My whiskers around my mouth and on my chin are coarse and the rest of them are medium. I’m not sure if this is normal for these blades since I often hear they are very good.

I am wondering what you guys think?

Do these blades appear to be counterfeit?

42 comments · 87% upvoted · source · other discussions

comments

AV-WS

It's written on the package in Turkish: made in China. Never saw greens from China though

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

Oh really? I guess Google Translate was wrong what part of it said made in china?

MOEB74

Top line- Üretim yert Çin

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

Ahh cool thanks

umutlukaybeden

According to the package it was distributed by P&G in Istanbul, that’s why it has the Turkish writing. That’s the same as Permasharp, they are made in Russia now but have Turkish writing because it’s distributed by P&G in Istanbul .

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

Oh ok thank you

OneCopy3082

The Astra SP models for the Turkish market are now manufactured in China.

[deleted]

[deleted]

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

But the factory moved to India I thought?

Where do you see made in china? I google translated everything and it definitely didn’t say that anywhere.

[deleted]

[deleted]

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

Oh ok that’s good info. So these appear legit considering that? I thought all production moved to India before people started responding in this thread.

Midnightmammal

I got this exact pack recently also and was confused why i couldn't find russia or india on the pack. Mine came from an online business here in Australia. I don't like the blades at all they feel rough and i got some nasty razor burn when i normally don't.

Just yesterday i got a new 100 pack from Amazon Australia expecting Indian blades but they were still russian blades supplied. I might order a few more packs to stock up i think.

OverturnedAppleCart3

i got a new 100 pack from Amazon Australia expecting Indian blades but they were still russian blades supplied. I might order a few more packs to stock up i think.

The problem with that is even if you order from the same store, you may get a 100-pack from a different source. It's just the way Amazon managed it's inventory. When you order a 100 pack from source A, it can be the one actually supplied by drive A, B, C, or D.

I would recommend RazorBladesClub. It may take a while (I assume you won't use 100 blades very quickly) but they offer free shipping to Australia for orders of 100 blades or more.

Midnightmammal

I forgot about rbc, thanks for the tip. It's also a good time to try some other blades as well

Hot-Comfort8839

I’ve been using them for years. That definitely doesn’t look like normal packaging… however I’ve basically been using the same hundred blade box for the last several years so it’s possible the packaging could’ve changed

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

Ok thanks for the input! :)

Marinoni427

I have these blades as well and they are awful. I would like to mail these to an Astra fan to try and see if they are a bad batch, fake or whatever.

[deleted]

Hi, just got this same astra blade form china ad they are very bad. I bought Astra cuz everyone told me that is a good brand, but this one from china is very bad

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

Thanks for your report!

pmk5252

I think I have these same blades that I got from Amazon too around November of last year.

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

Have you used them and if so what are your thoughts?

pmk5252

My son and I have been using them since I bought them. No issues but I honestly wasn’t paying much attention to those details but I guess I will be now. Either way I still have 100 of them to use. Have a great weekend

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

That makes sense. I’m gonna use them regardless as well. Thanks and you as well!

Glittering-Score2512

These green Astras have recently been manufactured in China; they are not counterfeit.

Lost_Reach5522

Got them in a bundle pack, one of my favorites’

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

This specific one from china? There are ones made in china, India, and Russia apparently and some say they perform differently even though they are all Astra green superior platinum.

Novel_Arachnid2828

Due to sanctions and logistics, P&G has moved production to India and partly to China. Your photo shows the inscription "Gillette.com" and information about P&G, which corresponds to the new global packaging. The new Indian and Chinese packaging have minor graphic changes compared to the old Russian ones. For example, the inscriptions on the side and the presence of a QR code (Data Matrix) are consistent with the newer batches from 2023/2024. The barcode in the photo (starting with 770...) is typical for Gillette/P&G products.

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

Alright thank you!

kwatah

I bought these on Amazon a couple of months ago, and they clearly say "Made in Russia." I decided to get more and reordered 180 blades, and they sent me the exact package as what you got. I opened one to see what the blade looks like, and it looks the same as the Russian one, but the packaging clearly says "Made in China." I'm going to see about returning them since they are not what I ordered, even though I did open one sleeve.

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

Man sorry that happened. Did you try them out? If so how did they perform in comparison to the Russian ones you had before.

kwatah

I put in for a return as soon as I got home. I ordered a 100 pack that ended up being a third the price. They say they are a product of India which I don't mind as long as I get them as ordered.

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

From the research I have done they no longer make astras in Russia and mostly make them in India now

kwatah

Apparently, some are made in China too. I'm giving up ordering blades from Amazon and will be ordering from razor suppliers now.

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

Yeah true the ones for the Turkish market for sure like the ones in my picture are manufactured in China. I am going to go through sources other than Amazon also from here on out.

EntertainmentOne9872

Hi, bin per Google hier.

Ich hatte vor Corona mal einen 100er Packen grüne gekauft die waren top.

Nun 100 grüne mal wieder, diesmal auch mit Türkisch drauf, aber innen das Butterbrotpapier um die Klinge ist mehrfach mit schnörkeliger Astra Schrift bedruckt und die erste Klinge war direkt kratzug wie ein Einwegrasierer aus der Drogerie nun frage ich mich auch ob es da mehrere Produktionsstandorte und Qualitätsunterschiede gibt oder Gilette im Rahmend er Shrinkflation nun auch am Hungertuch zu nagen gedenkt und die Dinger mittlerweile so mies sind?

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

As far as I know the only places producing green astras are china and India. The ones at top with the Turkish turned out to be Chinese produced. I haven’t tried India greens but the Astra blues I have are produced in India and work well. These Chinese greens I don’t like as well as the India made blues.

EntertainmentOne9872

I only know them russia made.

These now have a label sticked on in turkish as said where last line translated says like produced in russia, but old ones had another design, actual see photo, did they change that print on foil inside to that "new" design?

Hm, how add a photo? only available for the member starting a thread?

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

I’m not sure but specifically Astra greens and blues are no longer manufactured in Russia from what I know.

gerardgg

I just opened a box and the printing on the blade is different. It used to have 1,2 on one side and a 3,4 on the other side. now there's a U on one side and a 4 on the other side. I've been using this same brand for 9 years, I've always bought on Amazon, they've always been under 10 bucks for a box of 100 blades. I bought these about 6 months ago and the shave doesn't feel right and the print on the blade is different.

I checked the amazon price today and it is $8.24 for 100. That's way cheaper than it should be given our current inflation rate. So that's why I'm here, did they cheap out on us and send their manufacturing to some low quality chop shop? What do you guys think?

tayabuz

In my opinion, it looks like a fake. Gillette's factory in Russia has re-equipped the lines for marking blades and now there is no printing on them - only laser engraving. There is an uneven seal on these blades. I have an Astra from an older batch (they are made in Russia and have a stamp on them) - they don't have the uneven marks on the side like these blades have (I mean the T 2 mark on the side), mine just have numbers on the sides and the stamp is even.

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

I didn’t realize they were making them in Russia again. Everywhere I read said they moved production to India.

[deleted]

[removed]

Lackingfinalityornot [OP]

I knew the factory was still making other Gillette blades for both the Russian market and international market I just thought they moved the astra blues and greens to India.