Episode Discussion S09E07 - "No Questions Asked" (Here be spoilers!)

Use this thread to discuss S09E07 "No Questions Asked" of the final season.


Live Chat:

We now have our own registered IRC channel. Pop in any time to see if people are there discussing the show!

Follow this link, log in with your reddit nick and we will discuss live! Chat is open now, but picks up ~15 minutes prior to airing.


Reddit:

There will still be discussion here on this post, but we will be live in IRC as well.


DISCUSS!

ALTERNATE LIVE CHAT METHOD: We had some problems with IRC, so here is an alternative, in case the web portal for freenode is down. Use THIS LINK.

Type #himym into the channel and select Freenode under Featured Networks on the right.

468 comments · 93% upvoted · other discussions

comments

Lady_Tedwina_Slowsby

Priority Male. Classic

azizinator25

Not according to bazooka joe

dvars

Marshall's jokes were floundering.

thekotoz

Fish jokes. Nice.

broncosfighton

Trout... am I right?

load 1 more replies →

load 1 more replies →

load 4 more replies →

[deleted]

“Courtney Dove! I lost Kurt Coobain, I can’t lose you too!”

OccamsChainsaw15

He tackled Russell Brand because he stole the love of his life before he met Lily...Sarah Marshall

eddie_west_side

I thought that was Aldous Snow, singer/song writer of the hit single "African Child."

load 10 more replies →

[deleted]
Midwest_man

"You're saying you didn't order room service or Prison Sluts 9?"

"...I'm saying I didn't order room service."

vishalb777

Mama likes it dirty

gny7p

What happened to the Kennedy Package?

thekotoz

Linus only works there in the day. She would have to pay another hundred to someone else if she wanted it during those hours.

load 1 more replies →

PsycoMonkey42

This toy car has been there for a few episodes now. What role do you think it'll play in the future?

iluvhaters

ted will trip on in it and hurt his hand, thats why he has those bandages.

PeterGot

He will trip on a threat mill, crying "Ow ow ow ow ow" and then Barney realizes he can't be happy with Robin, and becomes a lumberjack.

klown_13

You. You. I like you.

load 1 more replies →

Shedal

So... you're saying there's one thing the writers thought through before starting filming?

Caraes_Naur

Winner, winner, chicken dinner cough .

load 2 more replies →

thekotoz

It was left there by some kid Lily yelled at while trying to talk on the phone in an earlier episode. Interesting that it's still there.

fcbarcaftw

Well.... it's only been a couple of hours since she told that kid to leave. So I think it's just continuity.. nothing else.

load 2 more replies →

pucykoks

No idea, but it's been the most interesting thing this season so far.

load 2 more replies →

azizinator25

I wonder what 6 people Marshall called between Robin and Ted

FreudianShart

I feel like the writers are asking us to watch this season no questions asked.

Smunny

Barney and Robin have had the same story every fuckin episode this season. They start fighting about something, then say maybe they're not right for each other in some way. Then they make up and don't learn anything whilst saying some line at the same time. Aww! Please stop.

[deleted]

[deleted]

broncosfighton

Next week on HIMYM: Barney and Robin still just don't seem to be working out! But will they work out? Tune in to find out absolutely nothing!

[deleted]

Ut Oh! It looks like Ted still loves Robin!

slide whistle

SegataSanshiro

EVERY.

SINGLE.

EPISODE.

I'm not even all that picky, frankly! I really am not! I don't generally notice or get annoyed by a rehashed formula if they at least wait half a season to do it again!

But seriously we're talking several consecutive episodes here.

fco83

Meanwhile we could be having say.. a minor story featuring what the mother is up to.

WandererAboveFog

Yeah this whole thing where they say something violent or inappropriate and go "AWWWWWW" together is just getting repetitive and boring.

Lugonn

It sucks from a story perspective, and it's completely ridiculous in-universe.

How fucking weird would it be to learn a deep and significant lesson about your relationship every other hour?

load 15 more replies →

ilaughlikemandark

What the fuck Robin. WHAT THE FUCK WAS THAT.

TheLantean

Mission for SHIELD gone sideways.

SegataSanshiro
[deleted]

Are Barney and Robin going to keep having conversations that they should've had before the weekend of their wedding in every freaking episode this season?

SawRub

Not to mention, each episode takes place over a few hours. So they keep having these conversations EVERY FEW HOURS.

venn177

It feels like they had a lot of material written, THEN they decided to frame it all around a 72-hour span of the wedding weekend.

load 5 more replies →

thekidfromyesterday

Damn Marshall must hate Russel Brand.

echoplex21

He did fuck Sarah Marshall...

[deleted]

I didn't get this joke until right now....

SawRub

Forgetting her took time.

kevinsetbingo

Damn aww moment between Barney and Robin, they aren't funny anymore. Stop it writers.

Corazon-DeLeon

I'm just hoping they're doing it on purpose so that they can eventually turn it around and have the gang notice how it's all they've been doing.

load 6 more replies →

[deleted]

The saddest thing about this episode is when Marshall told Lily about his Judge-ship they had a chance to have a really good HIMYM moment there that we all know and love, but nope, they sold it out for a mediocre joke.

[deleted]

that's exactly the same bullshit like the "I saw you and Robin at the carousel"

load 3 more replies →

echoplex21

You could actually completely skip this episode. Just pretend Lily read the message instead of Marshall telling her.

Smunny

We need some faster progression on the weekend. Not digging these past couple episodes. I mean some parts are funny but it's not what it used to be. Maybe it's this format, trying to get 50 some hours over 23-24 episodes. But I'm beginning to think that the writers didn't have enough material for a whole season. Maybe should've had just 12 episodes or something. I know I know. Money. But still.

foxtalep

I was just saying to my wife this season has been a big let down. We watch reruns almost every night on Netflix and watching this season has just been painful. The whole idea of dragging out this weekend over the whole season was just dumb. So now, we have story arcs like Marshall not telling Lily about the job and them being mad going over multiple episodes when it should just be a one episode issue. Ted's arc has just been painful so far... it's like the writer's said, "Well, we know he ends up with the mother so what do we do with him the rest of the season?"

venn177

Ted's arc

Wait, Ted has an ARC this season? I thought he was just being the kind-of-awkward best man that's also a great best man for the Robin-and-Barney get married show?

TruckstopStripper

I just can't imagine ever wanting to watch reruns of this season.

MrF33n3y

At least the next episode will be Saturday morning judging by the previews. Which means Marshall will be considerably closer to Long Island.

load 1 more replies →

Clinster

"Lily! I need your phone... No questions asked" Congratulations, you just saved like 500$ because iPhones are expensive.

mbene913

She can afford it. The captain is paying her so much mo-......oh God damn it Marshall

[deleted]

This season has jumped the shark completely. The last episode proves it.

The writers are taking nothing seriously. From Robin and Barney doing the whole 'awww' bullshit again to them having arguments they should've sorted out weeks before getting married, it's as if the writers are forcing us to believe they aren't meant for each other.

The whole ending was stupid as well. It could've been a heartfelt moment with Lily being upset and emotional after Marshall breaks the news, but nope, we get some cheesy crap with the lightning and 'you're dead to me' look. Robin was ridiculous with the ninja crap. They are all making fun of themselves.

I don't blame Jason Segel one bit for wanting to leave the show. There has to be some serious changes around to even get this show back on track. The mother will bring some of it, but it's sad that she is the glue holding the series together, while the other four characters are blatant caricatures of what they once were. Whatever little group dynamic they had is gone now with Marshall away in some car and Barney/Robin being annoying.

CapAhab

They could of built tension between Ted and the mother from the first episode. They could of met, and started their relationship slowly; becoming friends who bump into each other at the hotel every now and then, and soon realizing their love. Instead, a fucking nine season series about how a husband meets his wife is culminating in shit filler episodes that are forgettable and unfunny.

jwalsh1316

I was so annoyed at how they had lily react. it was out of characters for her and was just the writers pandering to the audience ofwhich is now no better Than a big bang theory facade

load 3 more replies →

load 12 more replies →

Dr_Ben_Dover

Rhys Darby!

Sportsfanno1

GO FUCK YOURSELF BRET!

jphobbit

We needed more of him.

ThatGingeOne

I'm from New Zealand and seeing him on HIMYM was so confusing! I actually had to go and check the internet to confirm it was him

load 2 more replies →

imaunitard

This episode is awful. It is like a parody of itself. Just smash your expensive phone. OK.

Marshall got arrested for chasing Bigfoot in central park.

All of the characters are caricatures of themselves at this point.

Ekks-O

Flanderisation all the way !

MrKentucky

Twice arrested.

[deleted]

The part where Robin in spandex was being chased was completely cringeworthy. That is something I would have written as a 15 year old and thought it was hilarious

[deleted]

[deleted]

HandicapperGeneral

I just don't understand the Patrice thing. She's so kind and pleasant, and all she ever wants to do is make Robin happy!

load 4 more replies →

[deleted]

Just lazy writing. He could've easily said he sent a text meant for another girl, and needed her phone to delete the message. No questions asked.

vishalb777

You can't say no questions asked and then explain what you are doing

[deleted]

True. Point remains though. Could've easily asked for her phone to delete a message no questions asked.

load 1 more replies →

load 7 more replies →

Lady_Tedwina_Slowsby

"One grizzly murder"

EDIT : Was wrong.

Portugalthemana

This show is not funny anymore, like at all. I'll continue watching it because I enjoyed it so much in the earlier seasons and want to know how it ends but fuck man this show is like cringe-worthy now. Makes me sad.

iwsavnthtbacon

These last few episodes have been so disappointing.

Lady_Tedwina_Slowsby

Damn. Lily looks good.

NatesYourMate

But Robin in that white dress though.

Volsunga

The Stormtrooper dress?

load 10 more replies →

load 1 more replies →

[deleted]
cjprussell

There's no excuse for this episode to not be a flash forward to next Halloween.

KryptKeeper

I'm actually pretty disappointed that wasn't what it was. I was completely expecting the first Halloween after the Mother gets introduced, maybe the start of a new tradition even. I'm going to be really pissed if the Thanksgiving episode doesn't include her since there's a very established tradition of going to Lily's house on Thanksgiving, and since the Thanksgiving after the wedding should include her anyway unless Ted "conveniently" leaves her at home. Maybe even include her in a Thanksgiving dinner photo and bring back the storyline about how Lily doesn't like Ted including "random bimbos" in their photos because they won't last. There's a lot they can do this season and it's really begin to irritate me that they're squandering good potential on really bad gimmicky episodes like this one.

load 1 more replies →

diabolical-sun

Alison, I do love you, but that perked eyebrow definitely ruined the scene. It's crazy how that one little thing downplayed the seriousness of the situation, but I definitely let out an audible groan when it happened.

Sgt_Pepper91

ooo yes! A Halloween episode not about the Slutty Pumpkin!

[deleted]

didn't Lily admit to being open to ghosts in a previous episode?

[deleted]

When she and Marshall get their slanted apartment, he tells her a ghost lives there and she believes him.

savageotter

maybe she no longer believes after that incident.

load 5 more replies →

[deleted]

Why do they have to add the stupid crazy things to the episodes? Robin running away from ninjas, dressed as a superhero?

Come on. Just take the show seriously. Fuck.

[deleted]

Even though it's a sitcom, there should be some basis of reality. It's not even funny. Disappointing episode. Robin looks good at least.

[deleted]

Thank god someone else pointed this out. It was so stupid. Sure, Ted caught in a mail bin was kind of funny. But keep it at that. Trying to keep on outdoing themselves led to unrealistic "Family Guy" style humor. This show should be more mature than that.

Yes it's a sitcom, and no it shouldn't be 100% realistic. But good god that ninja scene was stupid

venn177

You hit the nail on the head with the Family Guy point.

They literally are just using half the episode with Family Guy-esque cutaway gags. The parody of ghost shows could have been written for Family Guy it was so similar in style.

load 4 more replies →

azizinator25

I would love to see doves in Kevlar tuxedos

mrbananagrabber1

Really thought that brunette in the blue shirt at the end with her back to the camera was going to be The Mother when she turned around.

javierglz

That makes us two... hundred people. Maybe a few more.

Raktoner

THE MOTHER COMES BACK FINALLY

Lady_Tedwina_Slowsby

Next epsiode. Milioti said so.

load 6 more replies →

Vitalstatistix

This show/season is just further proof of the fact that as soon as you know you're leaving a job for good, you really don't give a fuck what happens anymore. This show fucking sucks now.

ChooChooTreyn

Of course Barney is a fan of Hans Gruber

OsamaVinDiesel

Hans Gruber. Charming international bandit. In the end, he dies hard. He's the title character.

load 1 more replies →

Raktoner

I was almost praying for Lily to have a rare understanding moment.

Sigh.

load 217 more replies →